India's Toy Story: Exploring the Export Turnaround and Policy Challenges in the Toy Industry

Unboxing India's Toy Story: Exploring the Export Turnaround and Policy Challenges in the Toy Industry

1. Indian toy industry has transitioned from being a net importer to a net exporter of toys in recent years.
2. The sustainability of this export turnaround is subject to debate, with concerns about short-term factors like protectionism and COVID-19 disruptions.
3. The industry consists of a mix of organized and unorganized enterprises, with small and medium-sized manufacturers dominating the sector.
4. India's share in the global toy market is currently minimal, but there has been an expansion of high-value exports to Middle East and African countries.
5. The industry is projected to reach $3 billion by 2028, growing at a CAGR of 12% between 2022 and 2028.
6. Inward-oriented industrial policies in the past hindered the growth of the Indian toy industry, resulting in stagnant and fragmented manufacturing.
7. Recent export growth can be attributed to factors such as increased custom duties and non-tariff barriers that led to import contraction.
8. However, it is too early to determine if the export turnaround represents sustained growth driven by government policies.
9. The impact of initiatives like "Make in India" and industry de-reservation on output and investment has been mixed.
10. Policymakers need to develop a comprehensive strategy that includes targeted investments, skill development, infrastructure development, and an enabling business environment to ensure sustainable long-term growth in the toy industry.

Unboxing the Export Turnaround in India's Toy Story: An In-depth Analysis of the Central Agricultural University (CAU) Imphal Faculty Recruitment and the Indian Toy Industry

The Indian toy industry has undergone a significant transformation in recent years. In the past, India heavily relied on toy imports, but it has now emerged as a net exporter of toys. However, the sustainability of this turnaround is a subject of debate, as some question whether it is a result of protectionism and the global disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic or a sign of sustained investment in the sector.

The Indian toy industry consists of a mix of organized and unorganized enterprises, with approximately 15,000 establishments in total. The sector employs around 35,000 workers and has a domestic market size estimated at $1.5 billion. It is dominated by small and medium-sized manufacturers, with over 4,000 toy units in the MSME sector contributing significantly to manufacturing and exports.

Despite the recent export growth, India's share in the global toy market remains relatively low, accounting for only half a percentage point of total exports. Between 2014 and 2019, the industry witnessed negative productivity growth, and imports constituted up to 80% of domestic sales. However, there has been an expansion of the Indian toy industry's global presence in recent years, particularly in high-value exports to Middle East and African countries. The sector is projected to reach $3 billion by 2028, growing at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 12% between 2022 and 2028.

The negligible share of India in the global toy market can be attributed to the country's inward-oriented industrial policy during the Planning-era. Unlike successful industrializing nations in Asia such as Japan, China, and Vietnam, India focused on sheltering domestic production through import tariffs and product reservation policies. As a result, toy manufacturing in India remained stagnant, outdated, and fragmented, while imports of modern and branded toys surged.

The recent export turnaround and import contraction in the Indian toy industry can be attributed to various factors. Indian toy exports have increased sixfold between 2013-14 and 2021-22, with toys being recognized as a champion sector with significant export potential. On the other hand, imports have declined due to increased custom duties and non-tariff barriers imposed by the government, such as production registration orders and safety regulation codes.

However, it is too early to determine whether this export turnaround represents sustained growth driven by government policies. The data available is limited to just two recent years, and the COVID-19 pandemic may have influenced the short-term outcomes. Furthermore, the industry has not made substantial investments to boost output and exports, and the turnaround does not seem to be the result of strengthening domestic investment and production on a sustained basis.

The government has implemented various policy initiatives to impact the toy industry, including the "Make in India" campaign and de-reservation of the industry. However, the impact of these initiatives has been mixed, with fluctuations in output, investment, and productivity growth. Additional government schemes, both at the central and state levels, have been introduced to strengthen the toy industry, offering incentives such as capital subsidies, duty exemptions, and interest subsidies.

To achieve sustainable long-term growth in the toy industry, policymakers need to move beyond simplistic binaries and tailor policies to the specific needs of industrial locations and clusters. A comprehensive strategy should encompass a combination of planning and reforms, focusing on nurturing the industry through targeted investments, skill development, infrastructure development, and creating an enabling business environment.

In conclusion, while the export turnaround in the Indian toy industry is a positive development, its long-term sustainability and growth depend on sustained investments, policy support, and a holistic approach that addresses the challenges faced by the sector. With the right strategies and policies in place, India has the potential to become a major player in the global toy market.

Thank You