Management as a Profession

Management as a Profession

Over the span of several decades, a multitude of factors, including the expansion of business entities, the dissociation of ownership from management, and intensifying competition, have ushered in a heightened demand for managers with professional qualifications. The role of a manager has evolved into a specialized endeavor, leading to a state in which proficient management is paramount.

A profession can be delineated as an occupation necessitating specialized knowledge and extensive academic groundwork, overseen by a representative body that regulates entry. Key components that define a profession encompass:

1. Specialized Knowledge: A profession mandates the presence of a structured knowledge base applicable to the development of professionals. Attaining mastery over principles and techniques is an integral endeavor for any professional. Similarly, a manager must dedicate themselves to cultivating expertise in the realm of management.

2. Formal Education & Training: Professions entail prescribed educational pathways and training. Prospective professionals undergo designated courses of study, which are typically offered by institutes and universities. Numerous management institutes have emerged to impart education and training. For instance, a Chartered Accountant (CA) cannot engage in auditing activities without the requisite degree or diploma. However, no statutory requirements or mandated courses exist for managers, although an MBA might be preferred.

3. Social Commitment: While professions sustain livelihoods, professionals are fundamentally driven by a desire to serve society. Their actions are guided by societal norms and values. In a parallel vein, a manager's responsibilities extend beyond proprietors to encompass society. Hence, managers are expected to furnish quality products at equitable prices.

4. Code of Ethics: Professions mandate adherence to a code of ethics containing regulations, honesty standards, integrity, and distinctive ethical principles. A representative association enforces this code, fostering self-discipline among members. Deviation from this code can result in penalties, including the revocation of membership. While the All India Management Association (AIMA) prescribes a code of ethics for managers, it lacks the legal prerogative to prosecute violators.

5. Representative Organization: A representative body is integral for governing a profession. For instance, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India establishes and oversees competence standards for auditors. Conversely, the AIMA lacks statutory authority to regulate managerial practices.

While management adheres to many facets of a profession, it does not attain full-fledged professional status due to several reasons:

• It lacks stringent entry barriers into managerial roles.

• No minimum educational prerequisites are established for managers.

• No managerial association holds the mandate to confer practice certificates.

• The AIMA's formulated code must be followed by managers, yet it lacks punitive authority.

• Comprehensive education and training infrastructure is not uniformly accessible.

• Regulatory codes might encroach upon managers' operational autonomy.

• Managerial effectiveness is gauged by performance rather than credentials.

• The ultimate business objective remains profit maximization rather than pure social welfare.

Conclusively, the pursuit of management aligns with numerous attributes of a profession. Nevertheless, it is not fully classified as a profession due to factors that diverge from established professional criteria. As underscored by Haymes, the contemporary managerial motto resonates as "He who serves best, also profits most," reflecting the intrinsic balance between service and profitability in the realm of management.

Management bears resemblances to a profession, aligning with certain professional characteristics, although not in entirety. Here, we delve into the ways in which management intersects with the professional realm:

1. Structured Knowledge Dissemination: Management encompasses a structured and systematic body of knowledge disseminated to individuals aspiring to become managers. This knowledge is a product of continuous evolution and expansion, catering to various business contexts. These principles and concepts are applied in diverse business scenarios. Institutions, colleges, books, and journals serve as avenues for acquiring this knowledge. Notably, esteemed institutions like the Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) are dedicated to imparting this managerial knowledge. Admittance into such institutions is often determined through rigorous entrance examinations.

2. Entrance Not as Stringent: Unlike some professions with strict entry criteria, management doesn't rigorously adhere to this aspect. For instance, the medical field mandates that one must be a practicing doctor. In contrast, management roles don't impose such stringent conditions. Any individual can assume a managerial position within an organization, regardless of their educational background. While specific qualifications from reputable management institutions are preferred, they aren't mandatory prerequisites.

3. Code of Conduct Varies: Unlike certain professions governed by singular regulatory bodies that prescribe uniform codes of conduct, the managerial landscape lacks a centralized authority of this nature. Although organizations such as the All India Management Association (AIMA) exist to oversee their manager members' activities, membership isn't obligatory to hold the title of a manager.

4. Dynamic Objectives: Management in organizations operates with distinct objectives that differ from one entity to another—ranging from profit maximization to service quality. However, these objectives are not static; they evolve over time. Notably, the focus on profit maximization is progressively shifting toward an emphasis on service-oriented goals.

In summary, management shares attributes with professions, albeit not seamlessly. Its structured knowledge transmission, existence of dedicated educational institutions, and codes of conduct governing managerial activities resonate with professional traits. Nonetheless, the flexibility in entry criteria and absence of a singular regulating authority set management apart from traditional professions. As the managerial landscape witnesses shifts towards dynamic objectives, the interplay between professional features and evolving priorities remains evident.

Thank You