Popular Theories of Organizational Communication

Theory	Key Concepts	Proponents/Contributors
Classical Management	- Hierarchy and chain of command - Formal structure and authority - Clear lines of communication	Henri Fayol, Max Weber, Frederick Taylor
Human Relations	- Importance of interpersonal relationships - Employee satisfaction and morale - Informal communication	Elton Mayo, Mary Parker Follett
Systems Theory	- Organization as a complex system - Interconnectedness of parts - Feedback loops	Ludwig von Bertalanffy, Karl Weick
Contingency Theory	- Adaptation to the environment - Fit between communication and organizational context	Joan Woodward, Paul Lawrence, Jay Lorsch
Organizational Culture	- Shared values, beliefs, and norms - Influence on communication patterns	Edgar Schein, Geert Hofstede
Information Processing	- Encoding, decoding, and interpretation of messages - Information overload and filtering	Karl Weick, Daniel Katz
Network Theory	- Analysis of communication networks - Importance of communication patterns	Stanley Wasserman, Barry Wellman
Diffusion of Innovations	- Spread of new ideas and practices - Factors influencing adoption	Everett Rogers
Organizational Learning	- Continuous learning and adaptation - Knowledge creation and sharing	Chris Argyris, Donald Schon
Stakeholder Theory	- Consideration of various stakeholders - Communication as a means of managing relationships	R. Edward Freeman, Ian Mitroff
Communication Accommodation Theory	- Adjusting communication to fit the audience - Accommodation and divergence in communication	Howard Giles, Nancy Henley

Please note that these theories are not exhaustive, and there are many more theories and models related to organizational communication. Additionally, some theorists and researchers have contributed to multiple theories within this field.

Organizational communication is a critical aspect of any business or institution, as it affects how information flows within the organization, how decisions are made, and ultimately, how the organization functions as a whole. Over the years, numerous theories and models have been developed to understand and improve organizational communication. In this extensive exploration, we will delve into some of the most popular theories of organizational communication, providing in-depth explanations of each.

1. Classical Management Theory:

   The Classical Management Theory, which emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, lays the foundation for many subsequent organizational communication theories. Two prominent theorists within this paradigm are Frederick Taylor and Henri Fayol.

   • Frederick Taylor's Scientific Management: Taylor's theory focused on optimizing productivity through systematic analysis and control of work processes. His ideas led to the development of assembly line production and a hierarchical structure. In terms of communication, Taylor's emphasis on precise task instructions and standardized procedures directly influenced the way organizations communicated with employees.

   • Henri Fayol's Administrative Management: Fayol's theory proposed a more holistic approach to management. He introduced the concept of the 14 Principles of Management, which included elements like unity of command, division of labor, and scalar chain. These principles laid the groundwork for hierarchical communication structures.

2. Human Relations Theory:

   The Human Relations Theory emerged as a response to the mechanistic and impersonal approach of Classical Management. This theory emphasizes the importance of interpersonal relationships in organizations. Two notable figures in this paradigm are Elton Mayo and Chester Barnard.

   • Hawthorne Studies (Elton Mayo): The Hawthorne Studies conducted at Western Electric's Hawthorne Works in the 1920s and 1930s revealed the significance of social interactions and group dynamics on productivity. This study highlighted the role of informal communication networks in shaping employee behavior and job satisfaction.

   • The Functions of the Executive (Chester Barnard): Barnard's work emphasized the role of communication in achieving organizational goals. He introduced the idea of the "zone of indifference," suggesting that employees will accept orders only if they fall within this zone, which is determined by their willingness to accept the authority of the sender.

3. Systems Theory:

   Systems theory views organizations as complex, interconnected systems. It emphasizes the flow of information within the organization and how it affects the organization's functioning. Key contributors to this theory include Ludwig von Bertalanffy and Daniel Katz and Robert L. Kahn.

   • General Systems Theory (Ludwig von Bertalanffy): Bertalanffy's work laid the foundation for systems theory in organizational communication. He proposed that organizations should be viewed as open systems, interacting with their environment through input, throughput, and output processes. Communication is seen as a crucial element for an organization to adapt and survive.

   • Open Systems Theory (Katz and Kahn): Katz and Kahn expanded on the general systems theory by applying it to organizations. They emphasized that organizations are open systems that exchange information with their environment. This theory highlights the importance of effective communication both internally and externally to maintain an organization's equilibrium.

4. Contingency Theory:

   Contingency theory suggests that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to organizational communication and that it should be adapted to the specific circumstances of each organization. Joan Woodward and Paul Lawrence and Jay Lorsch are key figures in this theory.

   • Joan Woodward's Theory of Organizational Technology: Woodward's research in the 1950s identified three different organizational structures based on the technology used: unitary (small-batch production), organic (continuous-process production), and mechanistic (mass-production). These structures require different communication strategies to function effectively.

   • Lawrence and Lorsch's Contingency Theory of Organizational Design: Lawrence and Lorsch proposed that organizations should adapt their structure and communication processes to fit the demands of their environment. They argued that different parts of an organization may require different communication systems depending on the degree of uncertainty and complexity they face.

5. Information Processing Theory:

   Information Processing Theory focuses on how organizations collect, process, and distribute information. This theory is rooted in cognitive psychology and computer science. Herbert Simon and Karl Weick are influential figures in this area.

   • Herbert Simon's Bounded Rationality: Simon's concept of bounded rationality suggests that individuals and organizations have limited cognitive resources. Therefore, they rely on heuristics and shortcuts to process information. In the context of organizational communication, this theory underscores the importance of simplifying and streamlining communication processes.

   • Karl Weick's Sensemaking Theory: Weick's theory explores how individuals and organizations make sense of ambiguous or complex situations. He argues that organizations engage in a continuous process of sensemaking through communication. Effective communication, according to Weick, involves creating shared interpretations and reducing equivocality.

6. Cultural Approach:

   The Cultural Approach to organizational communication emphasizes the role of culture in shaping communication practices within organizations. This perspective was influenced by anthropological and ethnographic research. Clifford Geertz and Gary Weaver are prominent figures in this field.

   • Clifford Geertz's Thick Description: Geertz argued that to understand an organization's culture, one must engage in "thick description" by examining the symbols, rituals, and shared meanings that shape communication. This approach highlights the importance of interpreting communication within its cultural context.

   • Gary Weaver's Cultural Communication Paradigm: Weaver developed the Cultural Communication Paradigm, which focuses on how communication is influenced by cultural values, beliefs, and practices. This theory underscores the need for intercultural competence in a globalized world.

7. Critical Theory:

   Critical Theory in organizational communication examines power dynamics, inequalities, and social justice issues within organizations. Scholars like Max Horkheimer, Herbert Marcuse, and Nancy Fraser have contributed to this perspective.

   • Max Horkheimer and Herbert Marcuse's Critical Theory: These theorists emphasized the role of ideology and domination in organizational communication. They argued that communication can be a tool of oppression and control and called for critical analysis and resistance.

   • Nancy Fraser's Theory of Communicative Action: Fraser's theory focuses on the ideal of "communicative rationality" and how it can be distorted by power imbalances and inequalities. She advocates for communicative ethics and the need to address issues of justice and fairness in communication processes.

8. Network Theory:

   Network Theory examines the informal communication networks that exist within organizations and how they influence decision-making and information flow. Stanley Wasserman and Barry Wellman are notable scholars in this field.

   • Social Network Analysis (Stanley Wasserman): Social Network Analysis (SNA) is a quantitative approach that maps and measures relationships among individuals or entities within an organization. SNA helps identify key influencers, communication bottlenecks, and information diffusion patterns.

   • Barry Wellman's Networked Individualism: Wellman's theory suggests that in contemporary society, individuals are increasingly connected through diverse networks. In organizational settings, this can lead to more flexible and dynamic communication patterns.

9. Symbolic Interactionism:

   Symbolic Interactionism focuses on how individuals create and interpret symbols, signs, and meanings in their interactions within organizations. Herbert Blumer and Erving Goffman are central figures in this theory.

   • Herbert Blumer's Three Premises: Blumer outlined three key premises of symbolic interactionism: the meaning of things arises from social interaction, these meanings are modified and adapted through a process of interpretation, and individuals use these meanings to guide their behavior within organizations.

   • Erving Goffman's Dramaturgical Theory: Goffman's theory likens social interactions to a theatrical performance. He suggested that individuals in organizations adopt roles and engage in impression management to convey particular images to others.

10. Organizational Culture Theory:

    Organizational Culture Theory explores how shared values, norms, and beliefs shape communication practices and behavior within an organization. Edgar Schein and Geert Hofstede are key contributors to this theory.

    • Edgar Schein's Three Levels of Culture: Schein identified three levels of organizational culture: artifacts and symbols (visible manifestations), espoused values (stated beliefs and norms), and basic assumptions (unconscious, deeply held beliefs). Communication plays a crucial role in transmitting and reinforcing these cultural elements.

    • Geert Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions: Hofstede's research examined cultural dimensions such as individualism-collectivism and power distance. These dimensions influence communication patterns and management styles in different cultural contexts.

11. Stakeholder Theory:

    Stakeholder Theory emphasizes the importance of considering the interests and perspectives of all stakeholders in organizational communication and decision-making. R. Edward Freeman and Mitchell et al. are prominent scholars in this field.

    • R. Edward Freeman's Stakeholder Theory: Freeman's theory argues that organizations should not focus solely on shareholders but should consider the interests of all stakeholders, including employees, customers, suppliers, and the community. Effective communication involves engaging and addressing the concerns of these stakeholders.

    • Mitchell et al.'s Stakeholder Salience Model: This model categorizes stakeholders based on their power, legitimacy, and urgency. By analyzing these attributes, organizations can prioritize their communication efforts and resources.

12. Innovation Diffusion Theory:

    Innovation Diffusion Theory explores how new ideas, practices, or technologies are adopted within organizations. Everett Rogers is a pioneering figure in this theory.

    • Everett Rogers' Diffusion of Innovations Theory: Rogers identified five categories of adopters: innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards. Effective communication strategies should target these groups differently based on their readiness to adopt innovations.

These are just some of the popular theories of organizational communication that have evolved over time. It's essential to note that these theories are not mutually exclusive, and organizations often draw from multiple theories to develop effective communication strategies. Additionally, the field of organizational communication continues to evolve as technology, globalization, and societal changes influence how organizations communicate both internally and externally. Understanding these theories can help organizations adapt to the ever-changing communication landscape and improve their overall effectiveness.

The realm of organizational communication has significantly expanded and deepened in recent decades, coinciding with the rise of corporations and the adoption of managerial approaches to business operations. Management theorists have played a pivotal role in defining the structure, function, and purpose of organizations. Key figures in this field include Max Weber, Philip Tompkins, George Cheney, and Stanley Deetz, who have made substantial contributions to our understanding of organizational communication. In this article, we will compare and contrast their contributions.

It is crucial to emphasize the relevance and significance of organizational communication for corporations worldwide. Communication lies at the core of an organization's existence and profoundly influences its success or failure.

Max Weber's Classic Organizational Theory: Fixed Structures Max Weber, a highly regarded management theorist, is often regarded as the pioneer of organizational studies. His theory of bureaucratic organizations represents the initial effort to define organizational structure and elucidate the communication processes within them.

Weber's theory posits that organizations have well-defined roles and responsibilities, resulting in hierarchical, structured, and unambiguous communication. Messages flow in a top-down manner, minimizing confusion. Weberian theory establishes rigid, machine-like organizational structures where individuals contribute through clearly defined roles and responsibilities. Meritocracy plays a central role, with work allocation based on capabilities and seniority as defined by fixed criteria.

Tompkins and Cheney's Organizational Control Theory Tompkins and Cheney's organizational control theory builds upon Weber's ideas but extends them to organizations transitioning away from pure bureaucracy, yet not entirely embracing amorphous structures. This theory introduces four types of control—simple, technical, bureaucratic, and concertive—that determine how power is exercised within organizations.

These four control types correspond to the evolution of organizations from simple models to bureaucracies, to technically oriented structures, and ultimately to organizations where every member understands their roles and is deeply aligned with the organization's mission and vision.

Stanley Deetz's Managerialism Theory Organizational structures have evolved over the years, leading to theories that acknowledge changing norms. Stanley Deetz's Managerialism Theory is one such attempt to describe organizational communication and control in contemporary companies, recognizing political and economic interests and the need to represent and empower these diverse interests.

Deetz's theory goes beyond fixed organizational notions, considering democratic aspirations and power dynamics within organizations. It emphasizes that meaning resides in people rather than just their words, and it seeks to uncover the interests underlying these meanings. This theory represents a departure from Weber's faceless bureaucratic model and the somewhat improved control theory of Tompkins and Cheney.

In Conclusion It's essential to understand that these theories represent the perspectives and ideals of their proponents. They are not exclusive or definitive descriptions of organizational structures. Modern organizations, especially agile and adaptable ones in the 21st century, often embrace a nuanced systems view of organizational theory.

These theorists were pioneers in their time, and today's management experts build upon their ideas. In essence, each wave of theorists stands on the shoulders of those who came before, contributing to the ongoing evolution of our understanding of organizational control and communication.

Thank You